In a recent case, NCAT has decided that a landlord falls under no obligation to ensure that their tenants comply with the by-laws in a strata scheme.

The Case
The case of Filetti -v- Eales; Eales -v- Filetti [2018] NSWCATCD 66 involved a dispute about noise between owners and residents in an apartment building in Vaucluse, Sydney.  Ms Filetti owns and lives in an apartment in that building.  She claimed that the tenants who lived in the apartment above hers created excessive noise. Ms Filetti applied to NCAT for orders against the tenants and the owner of the apartment above, Mr Eales, to require them to treat the floor space of their apartment to prevent the transmission of excessive noise. Ms Filetti also sought an order to compel Mr Eales to require his tenants to comply with the by-laws concerning the noise, and an order to require Mr Eales to compensate her for breaches of the by-laws committed by his tenants.

The Decision
NCAT dismissed Ms Filetti’s claim.  NCAT was not satisfied that Ms Filetti had proven that Mr Eales’ tenants created excessive noise.  NCAT accepted that it had power to make an order to require a lot owner to comply with the by-laws.  However, NCAT did not consider that it could make an order requiring an owner to ensure his or her tenants comply with the by-laws.  NCAT observed that the strata legislation does not impose an obligation on landlords to ensure their tenants comply with the by-laws (although NCAT did find that a landlord had capacity to require his or her tenants to comply with the by-laws).  For that reason, NCAT dismissed Ms Filetti’s claim for an order for Mr Eales to ensure that his tenants complied with the by-laws.

The Claim for Compensation
Ms Filetti also made a claim for compensation against Mr Eales for a breach of the by-laws by him.  NCAT expressed doubt that it had power to make an order for compensation in the circumstances.  NCAT considered that the decision of the Court of Appeal in The Owners Strata Plan 50276 -v- Thoo [2013] NSWCA 27 suggested that compensation is not available in respect of a breach of a by-law either in NCAT or a court of general jurisdiction.

Conclusion
Ultimately, Ms Filetti’s claim was unsuccessful because she did not prove that Mr Eales’ tenants were making excessive noise in breach of the by-laws. However, the more interesting aspects of the case are the findings by NCAT that it cannot make orders requiring a lot owner to ensure his or her tenants comply with the by-laws or order one lot owner to pay another owner compensation for a breach of the by-laws.

For NSW strata legal or levy collection advice please contact us here or call 02 9562 1266, we’re happy to assist.

An NCAT decision allowing a lot owner to keep unauthorised renovations was recently overturned by the Supreme Court.

In doing so, the Court confirmed that an owners corporation must act unreasonably before NCAT should overturn a decision of an owners corporation not to allow an owner to keep unauthorised alterations to common property.

Read on to find out why Supreme Court Quashes NCAT Decision to Allow Unauthorised Works

For strata legal or levy collection advice please contact us here or call 02 9562 1266, we’re happy to assist.

Thank you Strata for your support in 2016, we loved sharing our knowledge on all things Strata Law.

As a wrap up here are some useful links from 2016…

• We shared our knowledge at Forums throughout the year
• We tweeted, 107 times sharing the latest in strata law
• We developed Strata By-law Templates for the new strata laws making it easier for you
• We posted, 30 times on LinkedIn with the latest updates
• We improved our Levy Collection App, thanks to your feedback
• We shared our knowledge through 54 newsletters
• We expanded our team to better service the strata industry

We’re taking a break from 23 December 2016 and returning on 9 January 2017.

We wish you and your families a safe and happy ‘Festive Season’ and look forward to working with you in 2017.

For more information check out muellers.com.au or send an email to enquiries@dev.muellers.4data.com.au and we’ll get back to you on our return.

As the holiday season arrives, we’d like to take this opportunity to thank you for your support. It is through the satisfaction and loyalty of our clients that we can truly be a success at what we do!

Thanks to you, the Muellers team have been busy helping communities throughout 2015…

New Laws

The new strata laws will kick-in 1 July 2016, so, if you are looking to speak to a team of experts in strata law, we’d be happy to help. The Muellers team has over 130 years’ combined experience so you know you will be speaking to a team with knowledge and experience.

In fact, the Muellers team resolved hundreds of strata legal matters during 2015 including litigation and dispute resolution, building and construction, strata disputes, strata by-laws, levy recovery, management and property development.

And did you know we can also assist with conveyancing, wills and estate planning, and commercial leasing?

Millions of Dollars

We also understand that raising and receiving funds for building maintenance and scheme administration is fundamental to an efficiently-run scheme. That’s why, in 2015, the Muellers team collected millions of dollars in outstanding levies.

Access 24/7/365

Based on feedback from our clients, we also enhanced our levy collection service with a new online system ‘Levy Collect’, making it even easier for you to access your matters 24/7/365, anywhere, anytime from your desktop, laptop, tablet or smartphone….giving you back time to focus on other things.

No strings attached!

Anyone who would like to trial our new online ‘LevyCollect’ app can do so by sending an email to jsmmarketing@dev.muellers.4data.com.au and we’ll be in touch week commencing 11 January 2016 with the details.

And that’s the wrap-up…

We are taking a holiday break from 23 December 2015 and return on 11 January 2016.

We look forward to working with you in 2016.

We wish you and your families a safe and happy festive season!

For NSW strata legal or levy collection advice please contact us here or call 02 9562 1266, we’re happy to assist.

The recent media attention concerning smoking in strata buildings reached a fever pitch when NCAT ordered the landlord of a strata unit in Potts Point to pay compensation to his tenant.

The NSW Government said that the new strata laws would make clear that smoking and second-hand smoke exposure could constitute a nuisance that could be outlawed.

So, what can be done about smoking in strata buildings? Can smoking be prohibited? Perhaps a smoking by-law,  let’s find out.

For more information read – Smoke Drift By-laws

For NSW strata legal or levy collection advice please contact us here or call 02 9562 1266, we’re happy to assist.